103: The Clown Motel

Gina (01:08)

Welcome to I Scream You Scream, your weekly scoop of the most chilling histories, mysteries, and paranormal perplexities. My name is Gina.

Kathryn (01:16)

And I'm Kathryn.

Gina (01:17)

And in November, we're telling each other stories about circuses while we enjoy slushies. If you already know us, welcome back. And if you want to see and hear more from us, feel free to join us on Patreon. Quick mention that if you join our new Hot Fudge tier, like our friend Britney did, shout out Brittany,

Kathryn (01:34)

Whoa!

Gina (01:35)

you can get episodes early and ad free. Thank you very much to everyone who has already upgraded from our extra scoop tier to hot fudge. We see you, we appreciate you, we love you so very, very much.

So grab a spoon and let's dig in.

I am back on the pear Yeah,

Kathryn (01:53)

I was gonna ask you, what are we eating? Okay.

Gina (01:55)

I'm I'm back to pear 'cause I thought I would give it a second chance

Yeah, I still don't like that.

Hey Yeah, that's incredibly mid. No.

Kathryn (02:03)

Still no. Wow, good on you for

trying again. That's not really like you. Like usually when you're done you're like, fuck this.

Gina (02:13)

I'm changing. Not only have I grown emotionally, I've also grown

Kathryn (02:16)

Yeah.

Gina (02:17)

spiritually, physically. I used to be a baby and now I'm five foot five. And

Kathryn (02:24)

You're

five foot five? Wow, that's tall.

Gina (02:27)

Dude, my mom doesn't believe me. She thinks I'm five foot three. I have had doctors measure me and tell my mother how tall I am and she won't but it's because she's five five

Kathryn (02:37)

Yeah, it's hard.

It's hard when the baby is bigger than you. My niece is taller than me. We don't talk about she talks about it. I don't talk about it.

Gina (02:48)

speaking of um up there in Wisconsin.

Kathryn (02:51)

my god.

Gina (02:52)

What'd you get up to this last week?

Kathryn (02:53)

Girl, I went to the World Series.

Gina (02:56)

Hell yeah, you did.

Kathryn (02:58)

I've come a long way since our uh Pfister episode when I was vocal about how much I don't give a fuck about baseball.

Gina (03:05)

Uh

Kathryn (03:08)

Which is still true. I still don't give a fuck about baseball, but what I do love is joy and like a mob mentality. So therefore

Gina (03:17)

Okay, yeah.

Kathryn (03:18)

Highly recommend going to the World Series. Endless amount of both of those things.

Gina (03:23)

Ha ha ha

Kathryn (03:24)

I will say, if you're gonna go to one, highly recommend going in Milwaukee. These people are crazy. Everyone was having so much fun.

But the game was great. We Milwaukee won. I went to game one.

it was very dramatic though, because they won for a second, and then someone like challenged whatever call the guy.

Gina (03:46)

Ooh.

Kathryn (03:48)

in charge called it the ump guy. I don't know if that's what they're called when they stand by the bases, but like the ref ump guy.

Gina (03:54)

Yeah.

Kathryn (03:54)

And turned out they overturned the call, so they had to like do it again. They had to like keep playing. They didn't actually win. And then they won for real. So

Gina (04:05)

So they extra double won.

Kathryn (04:07)

yes, we got to experience two World Series wins in one game. It was actually really fun. Yeah,

Gina (04:11)

my gosh. Wow. That's really dramatic.

Kathryn (04:15)

Um, yeah. Go baseball. I'm having a great time. This is fun.

Gina (04:19)

Listen, I know nothing about the game of baseball, but I know they're very fun to go to. You got hot dogs, you got Long Island iced teas, you got people screaming and yelling with big foam fingers. There's nothing

Kathryn (04:28)

Yes. my God.

Gina (04:31)

to not love.

Kathryn (04:31)

I did only eat two hot dogs,

Gina (04:34)

Oof.

Kathryn (04:35)

which is a big L for Kathryn. even Phil, was like,

not to disrespect, I didn't I wasn't gonna say anything because I didn't want to make you feel bad, but I was expecting you to eat at least three. And I didn't.

Gina (04:46)

Hm.

Kathryn (04:46)

I only had two. But

I will say the best part of all of this for me is The rhetoric on social media people are really rooting for the Pfister ghosts right now because,

Gina (04:57)

Hell yeah.

Kathryn (04:58)

you know, the other team is staying there. Oh,

anyway, that's that's what's going on with me. Man, I really hope

Gina (05:04)

Ha ha

Kathryn (05:04)

they win the World Series because otherwise this is just the most embarrassing conversation of my life.

Gina (05:09)

Oh, this is gonna be a delicious hindsight as twenty twenty if that happens.

Kathryn (05:14)

Next recording I'm gonna be like either

real relieved or real drunk. Cause I care about baseball now.

what's new with you?

Gina (05:22)

we had a a delicious, very British roasted dinner last night with some apple crumble.

Kathryn (05:28)

Ooh yum.

Gina (05:29)

And I've been really craving some sticky toffee pudding lately, so I think I might make sticky toffee pudding soon, and that'll be nice.

Kathryn (05:34)

Ooh, it's

that time of year for b I baked brownies the other night.

Gina (05:38)

y

Kathryn (05:38)

May have just been yesterday. I don't remember. Time's not real. But it was like,

Gina (05:40)

Ha ha.

Kathryn (05:41)

man, this is just all I want.

Gina (05:43)

Yeah, that's my that's my big update.

Kathryn (05:46)

This has absolutely nothing to do with anything, but sh just like speaking about notable dates in October, one of my favorite fun facts about my birthday in conjunction with my mother's birthday is they both have connections to Edgar Alan Poe. Do you know about this? Have I talked to you about this?

Gina (06:05)

What? No.

Kathryn (06:06)

October 3rd, which is my birthday, not mean girls' day, it's Kathryn's Day.

that is the day that he was found injured, sick, whatever, in a gutter, like under mysterious circumstances. And then four days later, on my mother's birthday, the seventh is the day that he died.

Gina (06:25)

wow.

Kathryn (06:26)

So I'm Edgar Allan Poe, for anyone who's curious. Yeah.

Gina (06:28)

I was just thinking, yeah, do you think you and your mom each have

like a little piece of his soul or something?

Kathryn (06:34)

Absolutely.

Gina (06:36)

on You know You know you do look like an Edgar. I've been holding my tongue about it but

Kathryn (06:35)

Don't you just look at me and think about Alan? Yeah. What silly stupid question, Gina All these years, yep, yep.

Gina (06:48)

You know what this just reminded me of? 'Cause I'm thinking about like scary spooky things, like at your Alan Poe scary stuff. You have a creepy clown doll that you still haven't introduced to our friends.

Kathryn (06:59)

I do.

Yes, I have not done that yet. I have him right here. Allow me to introduce you all to my boy Bubbles.

Gina (07:07)

my god. uh

Kathryn (07:12)

He's just tall. is Bubbles. I got Bubbles at the circus when I was about five, six, and I've had him and loved him ever since this guy is filthy. I never realized how dirty he actually is. but we love him anyway.

Bubbles was my first clown. I I want to make it clear, I don't have a ginormous clown collection, but I do have more clowns than the average person.

insofar as I have two

But you wanna know who has more than that? The person in our story today.

gonna be talking about the clown motel, but much to my absolute delight, the story of the clown motel goes back way further than I was expecting it to. So I'm going to start our story way back in May of 1900.

Gina (08:00)

Nice and old.

Kathryn (08:01)

Yeah.

Sorry, I thought I was gonna sneeze for a second.

Gina (08:05)

I was like, you you do look confused.

Kathryn (08:08)

Nineteen hundred, I think. Sorry.

Gina (08:10)

Ha ha.

Kathryn (08:10)

Um, okay.

So in the spring of 1900, a man named Jim Butler was out wandering in the central Nevada desert and accidentally stumbled upon what he believed to be silver ore. Jim chopped off a piece of it wherever he found it. I don't know what he was doing out there. He, I believe he worked, slash possibly owned a ranch. I don't know what ranchers do, but he was out in the desert doing something or other.

Gina (08:38)

You're really painting a picture.

Kathryn (08:40)

exactly

how this story's gonna go. There's not a lot of detail on any of this. I will say most of the story is like allegedly. Some say that. So like I kind of had to pick a lane. This is the version of the story I am choosing to tell. So this guy may or may not have found some silver. So he chops a piece of it off and takes it to what I believe I believe it's pronounced an assayer. Do you know what an assayer is? They like.

Gina (09:07)

Mm.

Kathryn (09:09)

They t like basically are the ones to say, yes, this rock is worth something and this rock is not worth something. That is the like

Gina (09:16)

Okay,

Kathryn (09:18)

a s they as-say whether or not it is worth something. I don't know if that's a pun or not.

Gina (09:21)

Mm

Kathryn (09:26)

I don't know if that's actually what it's called or if that's funny. So

Gina (09:30)

it is very funny. I give it a ten out of ten. That's good.

Kathryn (09:33)

Thank you. so he takes us to this assayer guy, and this guy's like, nah, that's just iron, no one cares. And he just takes this rock and tosses it into his weird little rock pile. Jim's like, that sucks. Seems like silver to me, but whatever. So he goes back, gets more of this shiny silver rock, and he brings it back to the ranch where he lives.

and

this guy comes, his name is Tasker Audi.

Tasker's like, is this silver? Seems like silver. Jim's like, I know, right? They

Get it tested again. believe the Tasker guy was also an assayer, or he knew an assayer, or something like that. Someone tests it and this other person is like, holy shit, this is silver. We start suspecting that original assayer guy just wanted to keep the silver for himself. Allegedly. I don't know. There

Gina (10:24)

Mm.

Kathryn (10:27)

At the time, the area where this was all happening was traditionally a campground for the Shoshone people who were a nomadic group of indigenous people who were foragers and they traveled throughout the like desert basins of Nevada and like out west and just that whole giant region. And this area was a frequent stop for them because there were freshwater springs. So it was kind of like the classic spot where

If you're in the middle of the desert, this would naturally be a place where people would gravitate toward because there was some fresh water. So, per usu, once the white guy found out that there was a little silver deposit thing, everyone was like, fuck you guys, this area is ours now.

people start kind of getting wind that there's silver to be found in this area, and this town starts getting buildup called Tanopa. for whatever reason, Jim was taking his like sweet old time to get back to where he found this silver deposit. I believe it was like months before he went.

back there to actually stake his claim on this silver that he found. I

Gina (11:38)

Jim.

Kathryn (11:39)

don't

I don't know what the deal was, but for whatever reason.

It took him a couple months to go and actually stake claim on the deposit that he found. and the way it worked was if you I actually I'm gonna be real with you, I don't know exactly how it worked. But what it's but what

Gina (11:56)

I was like, wow, okay.

Kathryn (11:58)

it seems like is like whoever found whatever valuable rock that needed to be mined, you could be the one to like quote unquote own that area.

So anytime anyone found any like silver, gold, any of that, you had a right to do basically whatever you wanted with it. Like you didn't have to give it to anyone. You didn't have to like hand it over to anybody. This was the Wild West. we're still in gold rush and all that kind of time period. the rock he just happened to find at the time was silver, but there were also gold deposits in the area as well.

He stakes claim in this area and he decides to lease it out. And that is exactly as it sounds. He would lease it out to individual people and they had a right to mine in whatever area they were leasing from him. And he and this tasker guy just split the, I'm gonna call it rent.

he essentially became, I'm sure there's an official term for it, but I'm thinking of it as like a silver landlord type situation. Yeah, I know.

Gina (13:01)

Nya god

Kathryn (13:06)

all of these people are coming to rent these deposits so they could mine for their own silver. And thus the town was born. Within a few weeks of them leasing the area, there was a population of 60 miners. And just a few weeks after that, it grew to 250.

And this was like miners and their families, I should say. within a few weeks/slash low number of months, this town grew from literally nothing and no one other than the people that they kicked out. I'm very much telling this from the perspective of the people who sticked claim on this land. There were people already there.

But as far as the official quote population of the town, aka the white people, it went from 250 in a matter of weeks to eventually it ballooned to 650 people there. And that's where it like capped out for a while. I don't know the exact population now. I think it's like 1500 or something like that. But it grew very quickly.

Within the first year, the area would produce over $750,000 worth of both gold and silver. And that was in 19 whatever, 1901, 02 money. Yeah.

Gina (14:15)

Holy shit. Wow.

Kathryn (14:18)

in that time period, the town would build up six saloons, first and foremost. We need the saloons, multiple restaurants, lodging, like hotels and inns and that type of stuff, but also houses.

And then doctor's offices, lawyers, post office, et cetera, et cetera.

The $750,000 that they made within that first year, that level of production would continue for the next 40 years. So when he found this deposit, it was like a proper deposit. they were really functional and they were able to live off of this for many, many years.

when you have a mining town like this, when people are so um I may use the word desperate to find gold, because at this point many of these people have been traveling out west for endless days. So if you know you hear that there might be a promise of silver or gold somewhere, you're gonna do your best to make your way out there.

mining is not for the faint of heart. It's very dangerous. It's extremely emotionally and physically strenuous and taxing can cause major psychological turmoil. It is stressful for the families that are involved. Not to mention the fact that sanitation wasn't a huge thing at this time. Basically, Illness is running rampant

there there is no escaping it. It was extremely treacherous to move into towns like this at this time. One of the first things that was created was the old Tinopa Cemetery.

And among the buried were, miners who died in mining accidents, young children and the elderly who didn't like have the strength or immune system to make it through. we all of course know the havoc that TB was causing around this time, but there were so many other illnesses affecting this area in particular because so many people were coming from so far and wide that everyone was just bringing everything out west with them.

you've got cholera was a big thing, scarlet fever was incredibly common, dysentery, classic R.I.P. to everyone who played Oregon Trail. Like just all of it. Yeah.

Gina (16:22)

I was just about to say yeah, that's what Dunn got me on the Oregon Trail, yeah.

Kathryn (16:26)

All of us, yes,

this is all to say as quickly as the town grew, illness and mining tragedies took their fair share of the community. So it would have much been much bigger if the doctors had been able to keep up with the illness that was involved with moving out west.

Gina (16:43)

Fascinating. I never thought about that.

Kathryn (16:45)

Yeah, that people were dying left and right moving out west.

jumping ahead.

About a decade in the winter of 1911, there was a particularly devastating tragedy in the Tanopa-Belmont mine. Early in the day on February 23rd, several miners suddenly got a whiff of smoke while they were 1100 feet down in the mine. Before they knew it, fire had engulfed the entire mine shaft.

And they would later learn that one of the candles that they would use to both check for oxygen, but also like just the very little light that these people had to work under had caught a pile of dry wood on fire. And it the entire shaft was just engulfed in flames. One

Gina (17:31)

my god.

Kathryn (17:33)

man named William Murphy, he was lovingly referred to as Big Bill, went back and forth numerous times.

to help get men out of the shaft. And the smoke and just effort that he put into like carrying these guys up through the shaft, caused him to pass out inside the mine. And he was one of the people that was lost in the fire.

17 men, including this big bill guy, lost their lives that day And in a town of 600 people, would I say 600, 650? That

Gina (18:04)

Mm.

Kathryn (18:04)

is a huge percentage,

so that was one of the biggest tragedies in the town's history. Certainly the first big one.

But it wouldn't be the last. one fire that took place in the fall of 1942 at the Tanopa Extension Mill spread into the surrounding area. And that fire claimed one victim, a man named Clarence.

David, who was also a miner. He

there's like varying evidence on whether this Clarence guy died in 1942 or if he actually died in the 1911 fire.

Because there is a headstone in cemetery, in the old Tanopa Cemetery, that says Clarence, a man named Clarence David was buried there in 1911, but there's a record of a Clarence David dying in 1942. So wondering if it's like a junior situation, you know, maybe like his father died in the fire of 1911, or it's as simple as

Clarence wasn't a super uncommon name in the early 1900s, so it's possible they're just two different men named Clarence David. Or, you know, one of the headstones got messed up and someone put the wrong date. I don't know. for the purposes of this story and the reason why this dispute matters is the timeframe of the situation, because it wouldn't be until 1985 that Clarence David,

Who either died in 1911 or 1942,

Gina (19:36)

Ha ha

Kathryn (19:38)

his children, Leroy and Leona, would open up the Clown Motel in 1985.

Gina (20:47)

Okay.

Kathryn (20:47)

So to

me, time-wise, if his children are opening a hotel in 85, it makes more sense that he would have died in 42, right? Because that would have been a 70-year difference unless they opened

Gina (20:58)

I mean I Yeah.

Kathryn (21:01)

it at the age of like

eighty, which like maybe.

Gina (21:04)

that's what I was thinking. Like,

technically, could be either of 'em. I think the forties is way

Kathryn (21:09)

Technically possible.

Gina (21:10)

more likely.

Kathryn (21:11)

Yes. That's my thought too.

My guess is they're just more than one Clarence David, and it's as simple as that, and we're all just like getting them confused.

for the purposes of this story, let's say the guy died in 1982. What? No, 1942. He died six months ago, okay?

Gina (21:24)

Hm Let's pick out an entirely different year. oh

Kathryn (21:32)

but yeah, like I said, his children, Leroy and Leona, are the ones who would eventually open the clown motel. And they opened the motel in honor of their father.

the reason it became known as the Clown Motel is because it was decorated with the 150-piece clown collection that their father left them. He was a clown collector. And that's pretty much all we know about this guy.

Gina (21:58)

Okay, what a legacy.

Kathryn (22:00)

Yes, genuinely I I like cannot stress enough how bonkers it is to me that the only information I could find on him

Was he died in a fire, one of two years, several decades apart. He has two children and he loved clowns. Like that is it. That's all the information that is out

Gina (22:15)

Ha ha ha. oh

Kathryn (22:17)

there about this guy. Um, which I love. I yeah.

Gina (22:20)

I love that too. Like stuff like this is exactly

why I love history

like I always assume surely we know everything by now, like everything is so well documented, but then you have this guy. Don't know

Kathryn (22:27)

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Gina (22:30)

when he died, but he loved clowns, you know?

Kathryn (22:33)

I'm

literally like as I was researching this, I'm like, man, I gotta stop keeping my journals because I'm realizing there's too much information about me out there. I really have to like be more mysterious. I wish people after I die only knew three things about me because this is delightful. Yeah.

Gina (22:54)

I do think we should form a pact that when whichever one of us dies first, the other one has to burn the journals.

Kathryn (22:59)

I have

I have that written down. Do you wanna be in charge of that? You can be we'll be in charge of those things, yeah.

Gina (23:03)

I can be in charge. I mean on there will be a

slight delay depending on where I live at the time, but I will throw

Kathryn (23:07)

Yeah.

Gina (23:08)

a Moltoff cocktail as hard as I can west towards your house.

Kathryn (23:11)

Well

so actually we'll let's let's schedule some time to talk about this because what my

Gina (23:17)

Okay.

Kathryn (23:18)

idea was in my twilight years I'm gonna host a bonfire and we're all gonna ceremoniously burn all my shit together. So just mark your calendar for

Gina (23:27)

wow. Okay. Oof.

Kathryn (23:31)

few or several years from now. I don't know, I'll keep you updated.

Gina (23:34)

A few years from now, G we

Kathryn (23:36)

no man, I'm not getting any younger.

Gina (23:38)

Oh my god.

Kathryn (23:40)

Back to the clown motel.

Okay, so this particular

clown motel was filled with the collection included plushies, porcelain figurines, wooden statues, wall hangings, you name it. Like anything that could be a clown was a clown. Twas the collection, therefore motel decor. When

Leroy and Leona first opened the motel. it was just a normal hotel. There was nothing like spooky or creepy or anything about it. It was just like a quirky, kitschy desert motel. You know what I mean? Like a roadside weird place, but like really benign,

while Tanoba is

Kind of in the middle of nowhere. It is on the way to a lot of places. It's right in the middle of the Nevada desert. so it's a stopover town, basically. It's a perfect spot for a motel for people who are like on long road trips, very popular among like truck drivers, motorcyclists. It's like a road trip stop. It was the type of place where like you didn't have to have a reservation, you could just be

like on a long drive need to pull over in a town somewhere and like they'd have space for you. It's like that type of spot.

Before opening the clown motel, Leroy, his wife Angie, and then also Leona ran a motel called David's And it was just down the road from where they opened the clown motel eventually. Fun fact, the L motel, so the one that they ran.

First, before the Clown Motel eventually became very famous because it is where Howard Hughes married his second wife, actress Jean Peters. the reason he chose the motel was because it was in the middle of nowhere. This town was like out of the way, and he wanted to make sure that, paparazzi and all of that didn't follow them to wherever they were getting married. So they chose this random ass motel in the middle of nowhere.

To get married. Yeah, super random.

Gina (25:39)

that's cute.

Kathryn (25:42)

Was not expecting that piece of trivia to pop up in this episode. Didn't plan on

Gina (25:46)

Hmm.

Kathryn (25:46)

talking about Howard Hughes at all. And for those who don't know, Howard Hughes, I don't really know why he was famous. He did like a whole bunch of things in Hollywood and then suddenly became an aerospace engineer. I don't know which thing made him most popular. He was played by Leonardo DiCaprio in the Aviator. So go watch that movie if you want to know about Howard Hughes.

Moving on. despite the hotel being really famous and kind of a landmark because of this wedding, it eventually fell into disrepair and needed to be demolished, even though they still owned it and ran it. I don't know what happened there, and I don't know.

why it fell into disrepair or how they got the money to run a new motel after it did, there's like a gap in the story for me there. So iscreamyouscreampod@gmail.com. If you know the hot goss of this part of the story, please let us know because I am curious.

anyway, they did end up opening the clown motel with all of these figurines. And 10 years after opening and just kind of minding their business, just being

like a steady motel. There wasn't anything really notable about the hotel. No one really talked about it. It was just another weird thing in the middle of the desert. they decided to sell they sold it to Bob and Deborah Perchetti. And the Perchettis were really well known throughout town. Bob was the director of the local convention center and he played a big part in uh

Just like the goings-on around town. Like within a town of 1500, he was like somebody. You know what mean? Um, he played

Gina (27:22)

Mm.

Kathryn (27:23)

a part in creating the local holiday Jim Butler Day, the man who discovered the initial silver or iron or whatever it was that led to the town being a mining town.

this Pracchetti guy was a big deal. when he was running the motel, the fact that he was so popular kind of helped the motel quite a bit. I think that that was part of the reason they wanted it to go to him um was that he could keep it running. Like he had the power to spread the word, basically, so that it could like boost its popularity.

So he really helped the motel succeed. The other thing that helped the motel succeed, the internet. Enter

Gina (28:08)

Hm

Kathryn (28:10)

the 21st century.

Moving into the early 2000s and 2010s, word started to spread about this creepy little roadside motel next to an old mining cemetery, because that's where it was. I don't know if I specifically said that, but the motel was built like directly next to the old Tanopa Cemetery. So where it used to be this just kind of benign, kitschy roadside thing, the internet was like, oh, but it's next to a cemetery.

enter rumors, etc. Um, people wanted to see the creepy little spot for itself. And that is exactly how it was described within these stories on the internet. In the early years, no one was talking about ghosts at all. The phrase that I kept finding, you know, when people were describing it in those early posts was just creepy. You know, clowns are creepy, people are scared of cra clowns. So a motel with a zillion clowns

It's just weird. It's like a nerving, The creepy reputation grew and grew until eventually the stories did start to take on more of haunting nature, I will say.

one of the biggest things that people would say when they traveled out to go stay here was that they had a feeling of being watched. That was like the initial, there must be something here. I know. What's running through your

Gina (29:36)

Ugh,

Kathryn (29:36)

head?

Gina (29:37)

watched by clowns like g

Kathryn (29:39)

That's the thing. Yeah.

So it's like right off the bat, and and I wanna be clear, I'm I'm gonna sound like I am a skeptic throughout this episode. I'm not saying that the motel is not haunted, but I do think in the early years, it was mostly that. It's like, of course you're gonna feel like someone's watching you because there's a million clowns all over the place. Like, you know what I mean? Like they are literally looking at you, you know?

Gina (30:05)

Wild

sentence that is bananas Okay.

Kathryn (30:09)

I'm not saying it's haunted, I'm just saying there's clowns, you know?

but but that is it. Like I think that it is one of those

the haunting at this hotel is more so born out of the energy people are putting toward it versus ghosts that might actually be there. Debatable, disputable, of course, but that is like my read on the situation, especially in these early years. Um people did also report, in addition to the feeling of being watched, they reported that they would see shadows moving in the corners of their room.

And the classic unexplained noises. everyone who stayed there would say that they would hear strange sounds that they weren't expecting to hear, unclear about where they were coming from, whether it was within the room, outside the room, like in the bathroom, outside the motel, whatever. They were like hearing unfamiliar sounds. Um, of course, everyone blamed.

The neighboring cemetery. It is said that the motel is haunted by miners who are buried there. Though none of them have been explicitly named, I I tried to find stories where people actually said, you know, I saw the ghost of so and so, or you know, I saw something that looked like someone who may have been so and so or whatever. It really I really didn't find any of those. I am cu I'm sure they exist. I'm sure someone has some somewhere.

So anyone who's stayed here, I do want to say, please let us know. iscreamyouscreampod@gmail.com I would love if someone has like stayed at this motel and could tell us about it. Um, but yeah, it was it was just one of those things where like the creepiness grew into shadows, and the shadows grew into stories associated with the cemetery. And

Then 2015, as a result of the persistent online rumors, can you guess what happened? Can you guess what film crew stopped by one day?

Gina (32:03)

Uh, I'm guessing it's a paranormal ghost show that are we saying their name on the podcast this time?

Kathryn (32:09)

Yes.

Gina (32:10)

Okay.

Kathryn (32:11)

Yeah, we'll say it. Because actually I will say not it was not these guys that I mentioned in the Peoria State hospital one. It was a different one. This one, it's Ghost Adventures.

Gina (32:20)

Okay. Got it.

Kathryn (32:22)

In my other one, it was a different one. The other one, I'll say.

Gina (32:27)

You'll never figure it out.

Kathryn (32:30)

And that's my that's my um fuck, what are they called? Riddle. That's my riddle for this episode.

Gina (32:34)

Ha ha

ha.

Kathryn (32:37)

Um yeah, Ghost Adventures stopped by. they did an episode on the Clown Motel. Zak Bagans and Crew and I will say, of all of their episodes, over the course of the million years that they were slash are on air, I don't Ghost Adventures I think still exists. It's just different now. Um

Their episode on the clown motel was one of the most compelling out of all of the episodes that they had. And I will say, I don't think I still watched in 2015, but I definitely watched all throughout college. most of their episodes, there isn't actually any evidence, and any evidence they found was usually off-camera, and just like what you got to see was people like reacting to the evidence that they

quote unquote allegedly found. But in this episode, they caught multiple things on camera. So that really did of perpetuate or escalate the stories about this place being haunted. Um and what I will say like one of the creepiest ones was they did capture one of the clown dolls moving.

Gina (33:45)

my god What?

Kathryn (33:46)

Yeah. Um

yeah, and and I've I've seen it. It it does actually move. Whether or not it actually moves, I don't know. There's always like I

Gina (33:56)

Mm.

Kathryn (33:57)

I don't know. I have like a love-hate relationship with that show. or just like those types of shows in general. We've talked about this, but they did apparently catch something. Um I remember watching it like

Again, I don't remember if I still watched it regularly back then, but I do remember seeing like clips from it. And I looked it up for the purposes of this episode and you do see it move. Um, I don't I don't know who it was, but one of the investigators was talking to a spirit through the voice box, and he was telling the spirit to possess one of the dolls and make it move.

And he's like repeating it a couple of times over and over again. And eventually you see a life-size clown doll that's sitting in the chair, you see its hand that was resting on its leg like fall, like move off of its leg. Yeah.

Gina (34:53)

Life-sized?

You don't even have the benefit of it being like a Toy Story situation where you can punt it if you need to? Fuck that. my god.

Kathryn (35:00)

Yeah. Well, and so

that is one of the reasons it's like kinda eye roll, because like could have been a guy in the clown costume. You know what I mean? Um

Gina (35:08)

Oh, that's also creepy. Yeah.

Kathryn (35:11)

I don't think it was. am skeptical of these shows. Not all of them. Not necessarily these guys in particular. But it I mean, it's one of those things where it's like you

You can only see so much, you know what I mean? Like you can either choose

Gina (35:25)

Mm-hmm.

Kathryn (35:25)

to believe that they captured something or you can choose to believe they didn't, you know. But it is

Gina (35:29)

Mm.

Kathryn (35:29)

on film. I I will say that. And I'm

Gina (35:31)

Yes.

Kathryn (35:33)

I'm not disputing that something happened in the Clown Motel. I am just acknowledging, I know there's a lot of uh differing opinions on these shows, and I want to acknowledge and respect that.

As someone who's also captured paranormal evidence in the past that no one believed was real. but yeah, I mean it is very creepy footage, if nothing else. that isn't the only thing they caught. They did also capture what appeared to be like a dark, shadowy figure moving kind of in the background. And then a voice did come through on one of the spirit boxes they were using. I don't remember what it said. It was just like a hello or something like that.

not as groundbreaking as a moving life-size clown doll. All of this is to say that, like I said, that the the moving figurine, I don't even can't even say figurine, the the life-size doll um was the big kahuna.

This evidence was the creme de la creme of evidence that they captured on the show. It is considered, one of the top, I'm gonna say like three to five moments in the entire show. Which obviously a pol a possessed clown doll in a motel next to a cemetery that you actually captured on screen, like that's that's gold. You know, I yeah,

Gina (36:49)

Yeah.

Kathryn (36:52)

it doesn't get better than that for a paranormal show.

Naturally, after that, the Clown Motel was an official dark tourist destination. People were no longer just passing through on road trips or, you know, taking a detour if they were driving relatively nearby. After this, people were coming from far and wide specifically to stay at this motel, made famous by this show, A couple years after

The episode aired, the Parchettis did put the hotel up for sale. these hotel developers bought it, and the only caveat that the Parchettis had.

For whoever chose to buy buy it, was that the main slash original collection stay with the hotel? Like you couldn't get rid of the clowns, these guys buy it, and not only do they keep the clowns, but they decide to renovate it to turn it into like an official spooky location. So now in addition to the clown.

Collection just kind of being there, it is officially like a horror movie hotel. Like every room has like creepy clown murals on the walls. There's like an exorcist room where Reagan is a creepy clown. There's obviously a Pennywise room, like things like that. And in addition, this part I love.

Because this is the part where I'm like, okay, actually maybe it is haunted after all of these years of rumors. Because in addition to the original collection, in the years since this Ghost Adventures episode aired, numerous people have sent in their own clown dolls and figurines and other memorabilia with stories of curses, possessions, and hauntings. Some people have written in for help, like

Can you please take this? I don't know what to do with this cursed clown doll. Others just want their allegedly cursed possessions to be part of this clown collection. So all of these haunted dolls, etc., clown dolls specifically, that people have sent in have become part of the permanent collection. so what started as an initial 150-piece collection has now grown to, I don't know the exact number, but it's hundreds.

decorating the motel and it only continues to grow.

Gina (39:20)

Oh dude.

That's so scary. I mean that I'm like I'm

Kathryn (39:25)

Mm.

Gina (39:26)

tickled by the fact this exists. Like this sounds very cool, but not for me. However, I do not believe. uh

Kathryn (39:31)

Yeah. You know, I

was thinking I was thinking about it because I was like, would I want to stay there? mixed feelings because on the one hand, like clowns. I think they're fun. But I get a little what's the word I'm looking for? Snobby when it comes to creepy clowns.

Because I like justice for clowns, I do get a little upset that so many people are scared of them, but it's only because it's one of those fears where like there are so many people who aren't actually afraid of clowns, they're just afraid of them because they think it it's like a thing to be afraid of. And I'm just kinda

Gina (40:10)

Yeah, I agree.

Kathryn (40:11)

like, Justice for clowns, like they're not that scary. I understand why, like, you know, Pennywise ruined it for a lot of us, John Wayne Gacy ruined it for the w rest of you know, like I do get it.

I'm just like can't we just have a cute clown every now and then? Can't we just have more bubbles in the world?

Gina (40:30)

I love a like an actual

when I go to a circus, the clowns are always my favorite part. I absolutely love clownery

Kathryn (40:36)

Yeah.

Gina (40:36)

and tomfoolery. But creepy clowns do creep me out. Yeah, and like that's

Kathryn (40:38)

But then there's the haunted creepy clowns. Yes.

Gina (40:41)

I couldn't stay at this motel because the explicit we are a horror

Kathryn (40:44)

Yeah.

Gina (40:45)

dark tourism destination with accursed objects. Yeah, I could I couldn't do that.

Kathryn (40:49)

Mm-hmm.

Like, would I have s loved to stay there in 1985?

Gina (40:55)

Mm.

Kathryn (40:55)

Yes, But I'm a little like bitter about the fact that it has become not just a clown motel, but a creepy clown motel. Like I would

Gina (41:03)

Yeah.

Kathryn (41:03)

have liked it to just stay a nice, happy, fun clown motel,

Gina (41:07)

you know what you could do?

Kathryn (41:09)

What?

Gina (41:10)

Well, I mean history shows this town is big enough for two motels 'cause they used to have two of So you could open up a second motel and be the happy clown motel.

Kathryn (41:17)

Happy Clown Motel.

Send me all of your happy clowns out there, because right now I just have the two.

Gina (41:22)

Yeah.

Kathryn (41:27)

I will say, after everything I just said, I found myself in the area, I'm not gonna sit here and pretend I wouldn't stay there. Because I would. You know, I just I

Gina (41:37)

Yeah, respect.

Kathryn (41:38)

do wish that it was a fun, happy clown motel instead. Nothing sacred anymore.

Gina (41:46)

Ha ha ha

Kathryn (41:48)

Uh yeah, that's it. That's my show. Not show. What? I'm an episode. That's it everybody. Good night, everyone.

Gina (41:55)

folks Oh

man, how creepy. Do you mind if I look up some pictures of this place real quick? I want a visual aid. Okay.

Kathryn (42:05)

No, please do. I'll yeah, I'll

include them in in the video and like I'll have some for social. It's really fun looking from the outside. Like it

Gina (42:17)

Speak for yourself, Kathryn. my

Kathryn (42:21)

Okay, well i uh creepy,

But it

looks beautiful from the outside. Because like the

Gina (42:27)

Like, okay, yes.

Kathryn (42:29)

land and crap, yeah.

Gina (42:31)

And it is a a beautiful like the decoration is well done. And the outside does look very merry and happy and clownish and stuff. But I do think it still looks really scary. Whew. Fascinating. And it all started

Kathryn (42:45)

Yeah.

Gina (42:46)

because some dude was like, is this silver or not?

Kathryn (42:51)

Yeah, it really did. Yeah. So wild. And it remains

Gina (42:52)

Great. Love the Wild West. It's truly, truly wild. Oh, okay.

Kathryn (42:58)

remains crazy. Alright, do you have anything that

closes out?

Gina (43:02)

I do have something for you. I have a choice to give you to present. No, you don't.

Kathryn (43:06)

my god, I love choices.

No, I don't. I really, really hate that we're doing this, but thank you for being part of my life.

Gina (43:15)

Well, I'll give you the choice and if you can't

choose, I will happily choose for you.

Kathryn (43:18)

Okay. Okay.

Gina (43:19)

I have two stories. One of them is absolutely terrifying. One of them is not super scary, but it's an interesting format that I haven't seen before.

Kathryn (43:28)

Oh Okay. Damn, I don't know which one to choose.

Gina (43:32)

I will say that both of both options are fiction and both are okay,

Kathryn (43:37)

Okay, that was gonna be a question.

Gina (43:39)

great, same page. Yeah, both are fiction, both are Reddit stories.

Kathryn (43:44)

Okay. I am in the mood to be scared. So I'm gonna choose the one that's terrifying. Oh no!

Gina (43:49)

Ho ho ho Okay.

This one really quite scared the pants off of me, I shan't lie. But maybe you'll

Kathryn (43:57)

Okay.

Gina (43:58)

be fine. I don't know. Okay, so

Kathryn (43:59)

God.

Gina (44:02)

So this is called I Should Have Read the Reviews, and it comes from a user, Maliagirl1314 and it's from the short scary stories subreddit. Very good for

Kathryn (44:12)

Okay.

Gina (44:13)

bite-sized terror. Anyway, so story goes.

Kathryn (44:16)

Ha ha.

Gina (44:17)

My girlfriend moved out three weeks ago. My cat, Ruk was really close to her, and now that she's gone, I can tell that he's a bit lonely, especially when I'm at work.

I came home a few times to my curtains ripped up or all of the toilet paper in shreds. The last straw was when I came home after working late to find that he had clawed a hole the size of a dinner plate into the side of the sofa. Rue is in the process of doing the same thing to our sofa.

Kathryn (44:46)

God, yeah, I'm

I'm scared that this story's about a cat.

Gina (44:50)

So the cat's fine. I'll say the cat's fine.

Kathryn (44:53)

Okay, but is

the cat evil?

Gina (44:55)

I mean probably, but insofar as like all cats are kind of evil. All

Kathryn (44:58)

Yeah, that's fair. That's fair. Okay.

Gina (45:01)

I decided I had to do something. I tried different toys, even catnip, but nothing worked. One night while browsing Amazon, I saw a pet camera. It's a tiny camera

Kathryn (45:11)

Hmm.

Gina (45:11)

that records your pet on a live feed so you can monitor their behavior while you're away. It even has an audio function so you can talk to them. Sounded silly, but hey, I love my furry dude, so I bought it. I got overnight shipping and installed it immediately.

I decided to set it up in my bedroom, since that was where Ruk dwelled the most. My first day at work, I think I checked that camera 30 times. When I spoke into the microphone, Ruk seemed happier, and I noticed there was no destruction around the house either. And by day four, I figured I had solved the problem with Ruk That leads me to right now. About 30 minutes ago, I climbed into bed with Ruk ready to close my eyes, when my phone buzzed.

A notification from the pet cam. I almost ignored it, sure I had just triggered the thing, but I opened it anyway. And what I saw made my grip tighten on the phone. Instead of a video of myself in bed, I saw a man, tall, gangly, with pale skin and large eyes. He was moving into my room with exaggerated steps, like a sneaking cartoon character.

He got right up to the lens, so close that I could almost smell his rotten breath, and he smiled. I am

Kathryn (46:34)

Oh.

Gina (46:36)

I told you, dude, this scared the shit out of me. oh It's about to get worse.

Kathryn (46:39)

I hate it. I made a mistake. good.

Gina (46:45)

I immediately paused the video, terrified. I looked at the spot where the man should have been standing, but there was no one there. I went onto Amazon and I found the pet cam.

And read the reviews, hoping just for some weird glitch. It had to be a joke, right? The first dozen reviews were pretty standard, but it was the last one that caused me to bolt upright. The customer complained that the camera was on a time delay, sometimes as much as 15 minutes. I went back to the video and pressed play with shaky fingers. I watched in horror.

As the man slithered under my bed, giving the camera a wink before disappearing into the darkness. Then I saw mys

Kathryn (47:30)

god.

Gina (47:31)

I saw myself enter the room and climb in the bed before the video ended. Now I'm sitting here in my bed, knowing he's under it. I could call the police, but I doubt I would have time. So please do yourselves a favor and read the reviews.

Kathryn (47:49)

Oh my god.

Gina (47:49)

Ugh I'm

so sorry to have put you through that. It's so terrifying.

Kathryn (47:54)

Oh my god

Gina (47:58)

No, I know. I'm so sorry. It's so scary.

Kathryn (48:00)

That was awful. Can I tell you the ghosts

are literally the reason we as a family chose not to have pet cameras in this house?

Gina (48:09)

Yeah, fair.

Kathryn (48:10)

Like outside, fine. Love a camera outside. But I'm like, I just I can't I can't have a camera in my bedroom. And I definitely don't want one in my office.

Gina (48:21)

No. No. And I've thought about it. We've thought about doing like the food dispensers that have a camera on them. See as

Kathryn (48:28)

Yeah.

Gina (48:28)

you can like have like a laser pointer and stuff so you can play with the cats while you're

Kathryn (48:31)

Mm-hmm.

Gina (48:31)

gone. But A, they're really expensive. And B,

Kathryn (48:35)

Yeah.

Gina (48:35)

we live in like an old ass fucking Victorian building.

Kathryn (48:38)

Mm-hmm.

Gina (48:39)

Who knows how many ghosts are in here? I don't need to know what floats around and does stuff while I'm gone. Ugh.

Kathryn (48:45)

That's why

I stopped doing my because I used to have one of those like sleep tracking apps.

And I I never heard any I used to use it like way, way, way back in the day. And I stopped because I started, I could like feel my heart rate elevating every time I would listen back. Cause I

Gina (49:03)

Ugh yeah.

Kathryn (49:03)

talk in my sleep. So it was like kind of fun at first to hear what I was saying, but I was like

I actually hate this. I kinda don't wanna know what I'm saying.

Gina (49:13)

Yeah.

It it makes me think of dear David. God,

Kathryn (49:17)

Ugh yeah, me too.

Gina (49:19)

terrifying.

So everyone sleep

tight. Don't look under your bed. Or do. I don't know what the moral of that story should be. Maybe move. Just move. Just yeah, burn the whole thing down. Yeah.

Kathryn (49:27)

I don't know. Just move. Just burn it down. Burn it all down. Yeah.

Just burn your house down and go. Go be free.

Gina (49:35)

Good Lord. If you have a story you would like to hear on the podcast, hopefully maybe a less scary story than this one, you can send it to iscreamyouscreampod@gmail.com. Huge massive shout out to Clobear Money Coach for sponsoring today's episode. if you want to hear next week's episode right now, you can get it on our hot fudge tier on our Patreon page.

If that's not the vibe today, totally okay. We would also really appreciate if you could leave us a rating or a review wherever you're listening. That really, really helps us out.

We got one more circus episode for you guys, so that'll be fun. Not that I'm biased since I'm the one researching it, but it is a really interesting

Kathryn (50:10)

Ha ha ha.

Gina (50:12)

story. But until next time, keep it cool.

Kathryn (50:15)

And keep it creepy.

Next
Next

102: Harry Houdini